I like the definition of a community of practice explained as occurring in a social context where things evolve around common goals and where newcomers can enter and attempt to learn the 'ways' of best practice within the group.
So what is my community of practice? Of the top 3 that come to mind: Mindlab Hawke's Bay, Facebook Group; Accounting Teachers' Google Group and Schoology Educators a common denominator is that they are all closed groups. For the purposes of this blog I will be focusing of the Schoology educators CoP. Wenger (2000) 3 key elements are are satisfied by:
- Joint enterprise: The shared domain of the schoology educators group is demonstrate by the members having a commitment to and a shared competency about schoology; which is an online social networking based learning management system (LMS).
- Mutual engagement: the community is identified by joint discussions, sharing of resources, professional connects made and general help is given. Because the members of this CoP come from all around the world, activities are happening frequently throughout the week. An example is that someone can post a question to which others answer:
Or create a new separate group page for interested people to follow:
- Shared repertoire: a shared repertoire of resources: experiences, stories, tools, ways of addressing recurring problems—in short a shared practice. The schoology educators group has been created as: "This is a place for our community of educators to come together to discuss the successes and challenges of teaching both inside and outside of the modern classroom". There are a treasure trove of useful hints, resources and best practice ideas within the group to assist new and existing user of the LMS.
- But it is a closed group so does it satisfy the true intent of a CoP? If we look back to the definition opening this blog "newcomers can enter and attempt to learn the ways" I believe the Schoology Educators group is a CoP as the only reason it might be "closed" is that you have to sign up to schoology to have access.
I do have a strong sense of connectedness with this group as I receive (and read) updates by others on a daily basis. That said, I am somewhat of a observer. I only contribute infrequently. I am far more comfortable contributing to best practices with Schoology within my school in person, rather than on the international stage.
This is definitely my 'work on' area. My reluctance to blog is based on a similar fear of "what do I know, why would anyone value what I have to say, what if I get it wrong?"
Welcome back! Some random thoughts:starting at the end and answering your three questions - a lot; because you observe, think and articulate is why; there is no wrong.
ReplyDeleteNext up, this community of practice thingy - closed is closed baby. I'm no longer a Schoology member - therefore I'm out.
Finally - couldn't help thinking about Groucho Marx's famous quote - “I don’t want to belong to any club that would accept me as one of its members.”
Love and peace and blog on - Wozza
Thanks for your thoughts Wozza. Your comment that there is no wrong got me thinking. Everyday I stand in class and encourage (demand) that my students take risks and not be afraid to get things "wrong" as this is how we learn. Ironic then that I am not willing to model it! I vow to change.
ReplyDeleteClosed is closed, but it is only closed until you join. You can easily rejoin schoology so therefore is the door really closed?
Absolutely Toni this is an open community as anyone who shares the area of interest in schoology as a tool for effective communication can contribute. Your reflection re the expectation you have of your students and your response to sharing experiences and asking questions with your schoology community is valid and critical. Your colleagues believe you have a lot to offer this community however to grow yourself you need to take the plunge and make yourself vulnerable expose yourself to others who can confirm and or fertilise your thinking. This in turn has the power to increase your influence in other communities of practice you belong to.
ReplyDelete